Thursday, 27 February 2014
E10/ EF7 "" work
Boxer was a horse who had “steadiness of character”. (2)
Boxer, “an enormous beast” (2), was a friend of Benjamin’s.
SHORT, INCORPORATED
Incorporated means the quotation has been made part of your sentence. If the “” were gone, it would still be a grammatical sentence.
Boxer was a work horse who was “nearly eighteen hands high”. (2)
Boxer was a really big horse: “nearly eighteen hands high”. (3) NO GOOD, NOT INCORPORATED
Boxer was a big horse. He was an “enormous beast”. (3)
Boxer was a big horse who had a “somewhat stupid appearance”. (3)
Boxer was a huge horse who worked hard, and he was an “enormous beast”. (2)
Boxer, who was an “enormous beast” (2), was a dumb horse who worked hard.
Boxer, who was “an enormous beast” (2), was “nearly eighteen hands high”. TOO MUCH QUOTATION
Boxer, who was “an enormous beast” (2), was unusually tall.
WHERE TO PUT THE PERIOD?
Boxer was a horse who had “steadiness of character”. (2)
Boxer was a horse who had “tremendous powers of work.” (2)
DETAIL, IMPORTANT BUT NOT CRITICAL
Boxer was a horse who had “tremendous powers of work” (2) and who was huge.
…
… ellipsis
…… NOT ENGLISH , etc
I like dogs, cats, fish, goats, ……. NOT ENGLISH
I like dogs, cats, fish, goats, etc. ENGLISH et cetera, and others, ‘and so on’
… shows that words have been removed
Benjamin and Boxer were great friends and loved to hang out on “Sundays together… never speaking.” (2) MUST BE GRAMMATICAL
Benjamin and Boxer were great friends and loved to hang out on “Sundays… speaking.” (2) NOT GRAMMATICAL
Benjamin, who was a donkey, was the “oldest… and the worst tempered” (2) of all the animals. GRAMMATICAL
Benjamin, who was a donkey, was the “oldest… tempered” (2) of all the animals. NOT GRAMMATICAL
… POWERFUL TOOL, USE IT WISELY, USE IT SPARINGLY
[ ] square brackets- USED TO CHANGE WORDS, ONLY FOR GRAMMAR OR CLARITY
Stephen Harper said, “[Obama]is a very nice man.”
Benjamin and Boxer liked “spent their Sundays together”. (2) NOT GRAMMATICAL
Benjamin and Boxer liked “spen[ding] their Sundays together”. (2)
[] POWERFUL TOOL, USE IT WISELY, USE IT SPARINGLY
Boxer and Benjamin “usually [liked] spen[ding] their Sundays together… never speaking.” (2) UGLY, NOT ELEGANT, AWKWARD, BETTER TO REWRITE IN A DIFFERENT WAY
Boxer and Benjamin “spent their Sundays” (2) standing silently eating grass together.
Boxer and Benjamin liked to spend time in silence “grazing side by side”. (2)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment